USCIS denials

Your immigration case was denied. Here is what happens next.

A USCIS denial is often not the end of the case, but your options depend on the form, the reasons in the decision, and how quickly you act. Many deadlines are 30 days.

The short answer

Read the denial notice carefully and note its date. Depending on the type of case, your options may include a motion to reopen or reconsider on Form I-290B, an appeal, or a new filing that fixes the problem. Most motions and appeals must be filed within 30 days of the decision (33 days if it was mailed), so get the notice reviewed as soon as you can.

Some denials cannot be appealed at all. Most I-485 green card denials are an example. Some denials also affect your immigration status right away, and those consequences need attention separately from any challenge.

What happens after USCIS denies a case

USCIS sends a written decision explaining why the application or petition was denied. The denial is effective when it is issued. Filing a motion or appeal does not automatically suspend it.

What happens next depends on your situation. If you were in the U.S. relying on a pending application, such as a green card application, a denial can mean you no longer have a basis to remain. A work permit based on that pending application can also be affected. In some cases USCIS issues a Notice to Appear, which starts removal proceedings in immigration court. None of this is automatic in every case, which is why the details matter.

Why the denial notice matters

The decision letter is the most important document you have. It tells you:

  • The exact grounds USCIS relied on, often citing the specific law or regulation.
  • The evidence USCIS found missing or unpersuasive, and sometimes information it obtained from other sources.
  • Which options are available, and where and how to file them.
  • The date of the decision, which starts the clock on most deadlines.

Any challenge has to answer what the notice actually says. A response that repeats the original filing, or addresses a concern USCIS never raised, will usually fail.

Refiling versus challenging the denial

Sometimes the better route is to file a new application instead of fighting the old decision. Sometimes it is not.

Refiling may make sense when

  • The problem was missing evidence that you now have.
  • You are still eligible, and nothing time-sensitive depends on the old filing date.
  • A new filing is likely to be faster than a motion or appeal.

Challenging the decision may make sense when

  • USCIS misread the evidence or applied the wrong legal standard.
  • You would no longer qualify if you started over, for example because of a child's age or a change in the law.
  • The decision contains an adverse finding, such as fraud or misrepresentation, that would follow you into any new filing.
Keep in mindA new filing does not erase what is in the old record. USCIS will see the prior denial and the reasons for it, so a new application has to deal with those reasons directly.

Motions to reopen and motions to reconsider

Both are requests to the office that decided your case to take another look. They are different tools.

Motion to reopen

Based on new facts, supported by affidavits or documents. It is used when there is evidence USCIS did not have, or when something happened that USCIS did not know about, such as a response that was sent but never received.

Motion to reconsider

Based on the argument that the decision was wrong under the law or USCIS policy, using the record USCIS already had. New evidence is generally not part of a motion to reconsider.

A motion can combine both. Choosing the wrong type, or filing one without a real basis, usually leads to a dismissal. See our page on Form I-290B motions for more detail.

Form I-290B in general

Form I-290B, Notice of Appeal or Motion, is the form used for most motions to USCIS and for appeals to the Administrative Appeals Office in the case types where that appeal exists. It is not available for every decision. Family-based I-130 petitions, for example, are appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals on a different form. The denial notice should say which route applies to your case.

I-130 denials

An I-130 denial means USCIS was not satisfied that the family relationship qualifies, or that the petitioner is eligible to file. It is usually a decision about the relationship itself. The options typically include an appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals, a motion to USCIS, or a new petition. If USCIS made a marriage fraud finding, a new petition may be barred. Read more about I-130 denials.

I-485 denials

An I-485 denial is a decision about whether the person applying is eligible for a green card: how they entered, their status history, criminal or immigration issues, and the supporting documents. There is generally no appeal from an I-485 denial. A motion to reopen or reconsider may be possible. In some cases, the application can be raised again before an immigration judge if removal proceedings begin.

If the I-130 and I-485 were filed together and the I-130 was denied, the I-485 is usually denied along with it. In that situation the I-130 is where the problem needs to be solved.

Deadlines

  • Most motions and appeals to USCIS: 30 days from the decision, or 33 days if it was mailed.
  • Appeals of family-based I-130 denials to the Board of Immigration Appeals: generally 30 days.
  • A late motion to reopen may be accepted only in USCIS's discretion, and only if the delay was reasonable and beyond your control.

Assume the deadline is running from the date printed on the decision, not from the day you opened the envelope.

Common situations

Why cases get denied

01

Missing or weak evidence

The application was filed without key documents, or USCIS did not find the evidence persuasive.

02

No response to an RFE or NOID

A response was never filed, arrived late, or was sent to the wrong address.

03

Missed interview or biometrics

USCIS treated the case as abandoned, sometimes because a notice never arrived.

04

Doubts about the marriage

Interview answers, addresses or records left USCIS unconvinced the marriage is genuine.

05

Entry or status history

How the person entered the U.S., or past overstays and violations, made them ineligible to adjust.

06

Sponsor eligibility

The affidavit of support did not meet the income requirement, or the petitioner's own status was in question.

Our approach

How we handle a denial review

We don't promise outcomes. We tell you what the record supports and what we recommend.

  1. 01

    Read the decision and the record

    We go through the denial, your original filing, and any RFE or NOID and response, so we know exactly what USCIS had in front of it.

  2. 02

    Identify the grounds and the options

    We sort out which options actually exist for your case type, and what each would need to show.

  3. 03

    Recommend a course, with reasons

    Motion, appeal, refile, or wait. We explain why, what it costs, and what the risks are, including when we think none of them is worth pursuing.

  4. 04

    Prepare and file on time

    If you move forward, we build the filing around the specific grounds in the decision and file before the deadline.

FAQ

Common questions

Can every USCIS denial be appealed?
No. Some case types can be appealed to the Administrative Appeals Office, some family petitions go to the Board of Immigration Appeals, and some decisions, including most I-485 denials, have no appeal. A motion to reopen or reconsider is available more often, but it has its own requirements.
How long do I have to respond to a denial?
For most motions and appeals, 30 days from the decision, or 33 days if the decision was mailed. Check the date on the notice and do not wait to get it reviewed.
Should I just file the application again?
Sometimes that is the best option. It depends on why the case was denied, whether you are still eligible, and whether the decision contains findings that would carry over into a new filing.
Does a denial mean I will be deported?
Not automatically. The effect depends on your current status. If you have no other lawful basis to remain, USCIS may issue a Notice to Appear, which starts proceedings in immigration court. If you are worried about this, raise it at the start of the consultation.
Can I still work after my green card application is denied?
A work permit issued because of a pending green card application depends on that application. After a denial, it may no longer be valid. Ask about your specific card and category before relying on it.
I filed the case myself. Can you still help?
Yes. Many of the denials we review were filed without an attorney. We will look at what was filed and what went wrong.
What should I send before the consultation?
Every page of the denial notice, plus any Request for Evidence or Notice of Intent to Deny and your responses. If you have copies of the original filing, send those too.
Free consultation

Have your denial notice reviewed.

Book a consultation and send us the decision beforehand. We will tell you what options exist, what each one involves, and whether any of them makes sense.

NMG Law · 1901 North Olden Ave, Suite 7, Ewing, NJ 08618 · info@nmg.law
In person by appointment, or by video.
Call Schedule