Form I-290B

Form I-290B: motions to reopen and reconsider

Form I-290B is how many USCIS decisions are challenged, either by asking the office that decided the case to look again or, for some case types, by appealing to the Administrative Appeals Office.

The short answer

Form I-290B, Notice of Appeal or Motion, is filed with USCIS to ask that a decision be reopened, reconsidered or, for certain case types, appealed to the Administrative Appeals Office. A motion to reopen relies on new facts backed by evidence. A motion to reconsider argues the decision was legally wrong based on the record USCIS already had.

Most I-290B filings are due within 30 days of the decision, or 33 days if it was mailed. Not every decision can be challenged on I-290B. Family-based I-130 denials, for example, are appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals on a different form.

What Form I-290B is

The same form is used for three different requests:

  • An appeal to the Administrative Appeals Office, for the case types where USCIS decisions can be appealed there.
  • A motion to reopen, filed with the office that made the decision.
  • A motion to reconsider, also filed with that office.

A motion to reopen and a motion to reconsider can be combined in one filing. The decision notice usually says whether an appeal is available. Check the current filing fee on the USCIS website before you file, because fees change.

Motion to reopen

A motion to reopen asks USCIS to look at the case again because of new facts. Those facts must be supported by affidavits or other documents. Typical examples:

  • Evidence that answers the reason for denial and was not in the record.
  • Proof that an RFE response was filed on time, or that a notice was sent to the wrong address.
  • A change in circumstances that affects eligibility.

Motion to reconsider

A motion to reconsider argues that the decision was wrong under the law or USCIS policy, based on the evidence USCIS had when it decided. It must explain the error and cite the law or precedent that supports the argument. New evidence is generally not part of a motion to reconsider.

The difference, side by side

Motion to reopen

  • Based on new facts
  • Must include supporting evidence
  • Asks USCIS to decide again with a fuller record

Motion to reconsider

  • Based on legal or policy error
  • Uses the existing record
  • Asks USCIS to admit it got the law wrong

A motion is judged against its own requirements. A motion to reconsider that only adds documents, or a motion to reopen with no new facts, is usually dismissed without USCIS reaching the merits. Before filing, we work out whether the problem was the evidence, the legal analysis, or both, and build the motion accordingly.

When refiling may be the better choice

A motion is not always the best tool. A new application or petition can make more sense when:

  • The denial was for missing evidence that you now have, and a fresh filing would be decided faster.
  • You remain eligible, and nothing depends on keeping the original filing date.
  • No appeal is available and the motion would add little.

Refiling is a poor choice when USCIS made an adverse finding, such as fraud or misrepresentation, that will carry into the new case, or when you would no longer qualify if you started over.

I-290B deadlines

  • Most motions and appeals: 30 days from the decision, 33 days if it was mailed.
  • A late motion to reopen may be excused only in USCIS's discretion, when the delay was reasonable and beyond your control.
  • Filing a motion does not put the decision on hold. Any consequences of the denial for your status continue while the motion is pending.

What we review before recommending a motion

  • The exact grounds stated in the decision.
  • What was in the record: the original filing, any RFE or NOID, and the responses.
  • Whether genuinely new evidence exists, and whether it answers the grounds.
  • Whether USCIS applied the correct legal standard.
  • Whether an appeal is available, to the AAO or the Board of Immigration Appeals.
  • How the denial affects your current status, and what a motion will and won't change.
  • Time and cost compared with refiling.
Common situations

When a motion is often considered

01

Denied as abandoned

USCIS says you didn't respond or appear, but you did, or the notice never reached you.

02

Evidence overlooked

The decision says something was missing that was actually in the file.

03

New evidence available

Documents that answer the denial exist now but weren't available before.

04

Wrong legal standard

The decision applied a stricter test than the law requires.

05

A document misread

USCIS drew a conclusion from a document that doesn't support it.

06

Refiling isn't an option

Eligibility would be lost by starting over, so the original case has to be saved.

Our approach

How we handle I-290B cases

We don't promise outcomes. We tell you what the record supports and what we recommend.

  1. 01

    Read the decision and record

    We compare what USCIS said against what was actually filed.

  2. 02

    Choose the right route

    Reopen, reconsider, appeal, refile, or none of these, with reasons.

  3. 03

    Build the motion

    Evidence and legal argument aimed at the specific grounds of the decision.

  4. 04

    File on time and follow up

    We file within the deadline and track the case until it is decided.

FAQ

Common questions

Can every USCIS decision be challenged with Form I-290B?
No. Some decisions can be appealed to the Administrative Appeals Office, some cannot be appealed at all, and some, like family-based I-130 denials, are appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals on Form EOIR-29. Motions on I-290B are available more broadly, but they have strict requirements.
How long do I have to file?
Generally 30 days from the decision, or 33 days if the decision was mailed.
Can I file a motion to reopen and a motion to reconsider together?
Yes. Form I-290B allows a combined motion, and that is sometimes the right approach.
Does filing a motion let me stay in the U.S. or keep working?
Not by itself. A motion does not automatically suspend the decision or its effect on your status or work permit.
I missed the 30-day deadline. Is it too late?
For a motion to reopen, USCIS may accept a late filing if the delay was reasonable and beyond your control, but that is discretionary. Refiling may be the more realistic option. It depends on the case.
Can I include new evidence with a motion to reconsider?
Generally no. New evidence belongs in a motion to reopen. If you have both new evidence and a legal argument, a combined motion may fit.
How long does USCIS take to decide a motion?
It varies by office and case type, and it often takes several months. Check the USCIS processing times page for current estimates.
Free consultation

Find out whether a motion makes sense.

Book a consultation and send us the decision. We will tell you whether there is a real basis for a motion, and whether a different route would serve you better.

NMG Law · 1901 North Olden Ave, Suite 7, Ewing, NJ 08618 · info@nmg.law
In person by appointment, or by video.
Call Schedule