I-130 denials

I-130 petition denied: your options

An I-130 denial is a decision about the relationship itself: USCIS was not satisfied that it qualifies. How you respond depends on why it was denied.

The short answer

When USCIS denies an I-130, the decision letter explains the reason and the options. A family-based I-130 denial can generally be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals on Form EOIR-29 within 30 days. In some cases, a motion to reopen or reconsider can be filed with USCIS instead.

A new petition is also possible in many cases, but not if USCIS found marriage fraud, which can bar future petitions. The denial notice determines which of these options makes sense.

Why I-130 petitions are denied

Not enough evidence of the relationship

For marriage cases, USCIS was not convinced the marriage is genuine: few joint records, little evidence of a shared life, or evidence covering only a short period. For other family petitions, the problem is often a missing or unreliable birth record, or proof of the petitioner's status.

Marriage fraud findings or allegations

USCIS concluded that the current marriage, or a prior marriage of the beneficiary, was entered into to get immigration benefits. A formal finding under section 204(c) of the Immigration and Nationality Act bars approval of future petitions for that person. See marriage fraud allegations.

Inconsistencies

Interview answers conflicted with each other or with the forms, or records showed different addresses or timelines.

Prior petition history

The petitioner filed for other spouses before, or got their own green card through a prior marriage within the last five years. In the second situation, the law requires clear and convincing evidence that the prior marriage was genuine.

Document issues

A prior divorce that wasn't final, a marriage that isn't legally valid where it took place, or documents USCIS could not verify.

Appeal, motion, or refile

Appeal to the BIA

Filed on Form EOIR-29 with the USCIS office that denied the petition, generally within 30 days. The Board reviews whether the denial was correct. Appeals can take a long time to decide.

Motion to USCIS

A motion to reopen with new evidence, or a motion to reconsider based on legal error, filed on Form I-290B. Usually 30 days. See I-290B motions.

Refiling means a new I-130 with a stronger record. It can be the fastest option when the problem was thin evidence. It is not an option when there is a fraud finding, and the new petition will still be judged against the prior denial.

Petition denial vs. adjustment denial

The I-130 decides whether the relationship qualifies and whether the petitioner can file. The I-485 decides whether the person immigrating is eligible for a green card: entry, status history, admissibility and the supporting documents.

If they were filed together and the I-130 is denied, the I-485 is usually denied too, because it has nothing to rest on. The remedies are different. An I-130 denial can generally be appealed to the Board. An I-485 denial generally cannot be appealed. See what to do after a USCIS denial.

Why the actual denial notice needs to be reviewed

Two I-130 denials can look alike and call for completely different responses. The notice shows:

  • Whether USCIS simply found the evidence insufficient, or made a fraud finding under section 204(c). The difference is enormous.
  • Which facts USCIS relied on, and where they came from.
  • Whether a NOID was issued first, and what the response said.
  • Which appeal or motion route the decision identifies.

Deadlines

Appeals to the Board and most motions to USCIS are due within about 30 days of the decision, with extra time if it was mailed. Read the notice for the exact instructions and get it reviewed right away.

Common situations

I-130 denials we review

01

Inconsistent interview answers

Separate interviews produced different accounts that USCIS found unconvincing.

02

Insufficient evidence

The petition was filed with few joint records or other proof.

03

A section 204(c) finding

USCIS found a current or prior marriage fraudulent, which affects every future petition.

04

A prior divorce not final

The marriage wasn't valid because an earlier one hadn't legally ended.

05

No response to an RFE or NOID

The petition was decided on an incomplete record.

06

Petitioner's prior marriage

The petitioner got a green card through marriage within five years.

Our approach

How we handle an I-130 denial

We don't promise outcomes. We tell you what the record supports and what we recommend.

  1. 01

    Read the decision and record

    The denial, the original petition, and any RFE, NOID and responses.

  2. 02

    Identify what USCIS found

    Insufficient evidence, inconsistency, or a fraud finding.

  3. 03

    Recommend a route

    Appeal, motion, new petition, or a combination, with reasons.

  4. 04

    Prepare and file on time

    Built around the specific grounds in the decision.

FAQ

Common questions

Can I appeal an I-130 denial?
Generally yes. Family-based I-130 denials can be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals on Form EOIR-29, filed with the USCIS office that made the decision, usually within 30 days.
How long does an appeal to the Board take?
It varies and can take many months or longer. That is one reason refiling is sometimes considered instead, when it is an option.
Can we just file a new I-130?
Often, yes, if the problem was the evidence. Not if USCIS made a marriage fraud finding under section 204(c). A new petition should fix whatever caused the first denial.
What is section 204(c)?
A provision of immigration law that bars approval of any future petition for a person USCIS finds entered or tried to enter a marriage to evade immigration laws. It applies even to later, genuine marriages.
Does the denial affect my spouse's status in the U.S.?
It can. If your spouse's green card application depended on the I-130, it will likely be denied too, which may leave them without status. Talk to an attorney about this right away.
Can we appeal and refile at the same time?
In some cases. Whether it makes sense depends on the grounds of the denial and your circumstances. We will explain the tradeoffs.
Free consultation

Get your I-130 denial reviewed.

Book a consultation and send us the decision. We will explain what USCIS found and which options are realistic.

NMG Law · 1901 North Olden Ave, Suite 7, Ewing, NJ 08618 · info@nmg.law
In person by appointment, or by video.
Call Schedule